Skip to content
MPLADSTracker

MPLADS report card · 18th Lok Sabha

Dineshbhai Makwana

Lok SabhaBJPSC seatAhmedabad West · Gujarat

MP score30/100484th of 542 in the 18th Lok Sabha
26th of 26 from Gujarat
  • Payments concentrated with one vendor

    53% of vendor payments went to SOFTHARD INNOVATIONS SOLUTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED.

Allocated limit

₹16.04 Cr

Median ₹14.70 Cr

Fund utilisation

75%

₹12.02 Cr recommended · 233 works
About the median

Paid to vendors

₹3.41 Cr

21% of allocation
Below median (37%)

Works completed

2

0.9% of recommended
Below median (28%)

From recommendation to completion

Every work this MP recommended, by stage

  1. Recommended by the MP233 works

    ₹12.02 Cr · 75% of the ₹16.04 Cr allocated

  2. Sanctioned by the district179 works

    77% sanctioned · took 5.2 months on average (due within 45 days)

  3. Completed2 works

    ₹81.2 L final cost · 10.1 months from recommendation on average

54 works are still awaiting sanction, 27 of them for more than 45 days.

In plain words

What the numbers say

  • Recommended 233 works worth ₹12.02 Cr, a fund utilisation of 75%, higher than 48% of 18th Lok Sabha MPs.
  • The district has sanctioned 179 of them, taking 5.2 months on average.
  • ₹3.41 Cr has been paid to vendors, 21% of the allocation.
  • 2 works are complete, typically 10.1 months after recommendation. 2 works have geo-tagged photos on eSAKSHI.
  • The largest share of funds went to Health.
  • Payments went to 3 vendors. The largest received 53%.
  • No citizen ratings have been reported for completed works.

How the score is made

MP score 30/100: finishing works counts most

  1. Works completed 30%1Completed ÷ recommended works.
  2. Spending efficiency 20%24Value of completed works ÷ money paid out. Money paid without works finished scores low.
  3. Fund utilisation 15%75Value of works recommended ÷ allocated limit (MoSPI’s measure).
  4. Proof of work 15%40Share of completed works with photos or documents uploaded on eSAKSHI.
  5. Funds spent 10%21Paid to vendors ÷ allocated limit.
  6. Vendor diversity 10%
    i

    Members of Parliament (MPs) do not have direct, operational control over the specific vendors selected for government public works. However, they exert significant indirect influence by shaping procurement frameworks, passing supplier diversity laws, and conducting oversight.

    59
    How spread out payments are: full marks when no vendor gets over 20% of the money, none when one vendor gets everything.

Largest vendor: SOFTHARD INNOVATIONS SOLUTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, 53% of payments across 3 vendors.

District sanction speed

76/100 · sanction is the district authority’s job, so this doesn’t change the MP’s rank

  1. Sanction speed 100%76Average days to sanction (full marks within the 45-day guideline, none at a year), and the share of works not overdue.

Activity over time

Recommendations, payments and completions by month

Value of works MPs recommended each month

Who got paid

Top vendors by payments received

Implementing district authorities

The districts that sanction and execute this MP’s works

Works

233 works · the 60 most recent are listed here, all of them in the explorer · tap “Photos” to see geo-tagged photos from eSAKSHI

Open in explorer
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Valmiki Vas Awas Yojana- EWS qwaterValmiki Vas Awas Yojana- EWS qwater Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322126

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Maulona Azad Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322127

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Ews Qwaters-1, Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322128

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Fesal Park, Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322131

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Vankar Vas , Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322132

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Chamundanagar-2 Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322142

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Kailashnagar Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322143

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Vishalnagar road-2 Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322144

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Satadhar Society, Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322146

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Maharana Pratap-2, , Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322147

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Ayodhya Park-3, Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322151

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. New Indirinagar , Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322200

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Maharana Pratap-2 , Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322202

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Chandan Park , Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322204

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026
  • Toy box, Coboard, slide, PVC horse, and other essential toys for children. Jayshri Society Aganwadi Isanpur

    Sports & fitnessPurchase of sports equipment· Ahmedabad· #322209

    ₹20,000 Awaiting sanction · 2 daysRec. 30 Oct 2026

18th Lok Sabha MPs from Gujarat

Ranked by MP score

Compare
#MPUtilisationSpentCompletedScore
1C R Patil · Navsari83%48%27881
2Bharatbhai Manubhai Sutariya · Amreli90%47%20076
3Mansukhbhai Dhanjibhai Vasava · Bharuch81%47%23171
4Bharatsinhji Shankarji Dabhi · Patan88%57%16271
5Rajeshbhai Naranbhai Chudasama · Junagadh98%41%15771
6Mukeshkumar Chandrakaant Dalal · Surat83%29%10969
7Shobhanaben Mahendrasinh Baraiya · Sabarkantha77%43%13167
8Parshottambhai Rupala · Rajkot91%30%11567
9Dhaval Laxmanbhai Patel · Valsad64%30%7866
10Mitesh Rameshbhai Bakabhai Patel · Anand83%53%26765
11Dr. Mansukh Mandaviya · Porbandar96%28%8264
12Jaswantsinh Sumanbhai Bhabhor · Dahod90%21%9964

Source: MoSPI eSAKSHI (eSAKSHI API (mplads.mospi.gov.in)). Fund utilisation = works recommended ÷ allocated limit (MoSPI’s definition); spent = vendor payments ÷ allocated limit; completion = completed ÷ recommended works. The MP score weighs completion, spending efficiency, utilisation, proof of work, spending and vendor diversity. How it’s calculated.