Compare
Compare MPs side by side
Pick up to four MPs. The link updates as you go, so you can share the comparison.
Shri Samirul IslamRajya Sabha · West BengalShri Nagendra RayRajya Sabha · West BengalSmt. Mamata ThakurRajya Sabha · West Bengal
| Metric | Shri Samirul Islam | Shri Nagendra Ray | Smt. Mamata Thakur |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who | |||
| House | Rajya Sabha | Rajya Sabha | Rajya Sabha |
| Constituency / state | West Bengal | West Bengal | West Bengal |
| Money | |||
| Allocated limit | ₹17.15 Cr | ₹17.15 Cr | ₹14.70 Cr |
| Works recommended (₹) | ₹12.15 Cr | ₹12.24 Cr(best) | ₹5.47 Cr |
| Fund utilisationRecommended ₹ ÷ allocated ₹ (MoSPI’s measure) | 71% | 71%(best) | 37% |
| Paid to vendors (₹) | ₹7.22 Cr | ₹10.29 Cr(best) | ₹4.47 Cr |
| SpentPaid ₹ ÷ allocated ₹ | 42% | 60%(best) | 30% |
| Works | |||
| Works recommended | 57 | 22 | 60(best) |
| Sanctioned by districtSanctioned ÷ recommended works | 58% | 95% | 100%(best) |
| Avg time to sanctionGuideline: within 45 days | 5.9 months | 8.8 months | 4.1 months(best) |
| Awaiting sanction > 45 days | 24 | 1 | 0(best) |
| Works completed | 0 | 20 | 52(best) |
| Completion rateCompleted ÷ recommended works | 0% | 91%(best) | 87% |
| Works pending | 57 | 2 | 8 |
| Avg citizen rating | — | — | — |
| Avg time to complete | — | 13.8 months | 5.5 months(best) |
| Top sector | Health | Education & libraries | Community buildings & public spaces |
| Vendors | |||
| Vendors paid | 8 | 8 | 5 |
| Largest vendor’s shareShare of this MP’s vendor payments going to the single largest vendor | 51% | 32%(best) | 49% |
| Overall | |||
| MP scoreCompletion, spending efficiency, utilisation, proof of work, spending and vendor diversity. See About | 21 | 86(best) | 69 |
| Rank in house | 159 of 235 | 6 of 235 | 35 of 235 |
| Rank in state | 7 of 13 | 1 of 13 | 2 of 13 |
● marks the best value in a row where higher (or, for time and vendor share, lower) is clearly better. Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha MPs work under different rules; compare like with like where you can.